STAR Criminal Justice

Rural Americans deserve the same constitutional protections as their urban neighbors.

Rural communities are concerned about criminal justice reform: they want safe streets, fair process, and equal justice. But for too long the rural criminal justice experience has largely been ignored.

Rural communities are far less likely to receive the Constitution’s protections.

In criminal legal deserts—areas with too few qualified attorneys to meet local needs—rural communities suffer. Rural courts meet less frequently. Victims wait for prosecutors to investigate. Evidence disappears, and witnesses’ memories fade. Meanwhile, rural criminal defendants—who are presumed innocent— face tough choices. Will they languish in jail, waiting for a qualified attorney to defend them? Or will they proceed without an attorney, risking jail time, fines, and collateral consequences, just to put the criminal process behind them? The Deason Center is committed to making a sustained investment in rural justice research and reform to address this access-to-justice crisis. 

Featured Projects

 

Highlighting the challenges and opportunities in rural communities.

The Deason Center is the only academic center in the country with a dedicated focus on the operation of STAR criminal legal systems. The Center produces pioneering research to reveal the challenges STAR justice stakeholders face and drives national reform conversations about criminal justice in STAR communities. As an essential resource for rural justice practitioners and scholars, we are:

Investigating rural criminal processes and procedures

Advocating for research-based rural justice solutions

An group of stakeholders learning more about criminal justice reform.

Convening rural research roundtables

Engaging rural communities and legal professionals

STAR Justice Resources

  • Texas’ rural communities urgently need more prosecutors and public defense providers. Many rural prosecutor’s offices cannot recruit and retain enough staff. Rural Texans charged with misdemeanors are four times less likely to have a lawyer than urban defendants. This policy brief outlines three solutions to recruit more criminal lawyers to serve rural Texans: Educational pipelines, financial incentives, and rural public defender offices. Rural Texans deserve the same constitutional protections as their urban and suburban counterparts. With strong recruitment strategies, targeted incentive programs, and new rural defender offices, Texas can green its criminal law deserts. 

  • Rural Justice Innovations

    Rural criminal justice matters, and rural criminal justice innovations must be studied and celebrated. The Deason Criminal Justice Reform Center is pleased to join Rulo Strategies, LLC, and the National Center for State Courts, in publishing a report that highlights innovations in rural criminal legal systems across the United States. For too long, funders, researchers, and justice innovators have focused on urban justice systems, largely ignoring the rural criminal justice experience. And when rural systems are studied, the attention usually falls on their deficits—not their strengths. But the smaller scale of rural justice systems means that they can be flexible and nimble justice innovators. As this report demonstrates, there are countless lessons to be learned from rural stakeholders in the criminal system.

  • STAR Criminal Justice Bibliography

    The STAR Criminal Justice Bibliography is a rich resource for STAR practitioners, policymakers, and communities. The bibliography provides a helpful summary of scholarship that addresses STAR criminal legal systems. The bibliography emphasizes research that can be readily translated into actionable reform by STAR lawyers, communities, and justice-impacted individuals. Topics of special interest include public defense innovations, technological adaptations, and juvenile justice and reentry programs that are tailored to the unique characteristics of STAR systems.

  • The Rural Texas Sheriff reports on a focus group conducted in conjunction with the Center's 2019 Rural Criminal Justice Summit. The report places rural Texas sheriffs and their agencies in a national context. It also offers insight into the focus group's perceptions of rural law enforcement and jail management. With first-hand accounts of these sheriffs’ experiences, the report offers a compelling look at the personal and professional lives of Texas’ rural sheriffs.

  • Greening the Desert brings a criminal justice lens to the phenomenon of legal deserts in STAR communities—vast areas with few, if any, practicing attorneys. The report explores STAR criminal justice communities and describes strategies and initiatives to green these criminal law deserts. Using case studies, the report offers concrete examples of successful innovations. It also includes cautionary notes about risks that may arise with the implementation of strategies to recruit, train, and retain STAR practitioners. A companion explores the national landscape and chronicles how two STAR criminal lawyers found their way to rural practice.

STAR Justice Experts

Pamela Metzger

Malia Brink

Dr. Andrew Davies

Blane Skiles